Ad Clicks : Ad Views : Ad Clicks : Ad Views : Ad Clicks : Ad Views :

The Top 10 Reasons to Ban Me from Bay Area Science Festival

/
/
/
395 Views

Two weeks ago, PZ Myers pointed out that Dr. Eliza Sutton of the University of Washington in Seattle was the source of a rumor that PZ had contracted gonnorhea at SkepchickCon last year. Sutton posts on blogs and social media as “Skeptickle” or “Skeptixx,” where she has been open about her profession as a doctor, and has also previously declared her own name.

Obviously, a medical doctor diagnosing hated enemies with an STD is a gross breach of medical ethics, which is why a link to PZ’s post was Tweeted from the Skepchick Twitter feed, which we use occasionally for quick links that aren’t worth full posts.

I found her behavior so abhorrent that I retweeted the @Skepchicks Tweet. Obviously, this inspired someone to start a petition begging the Bay Area Science Festival to ban me from hosting my comedy science panel quiz show Quiz-o-Tron, which happens this Saturday, October 25, at the Castro Theatre. Advance tickets are only $10!

The petitioner Tweeted a link to the cause using the #GamerGate hashtag, which is meant to have something to do with the ethics of games journalism but, as made clear in this instance which has nothing to do with video games or journalism, is really just a flimsy cover for harassing women.

The #GamerGate crowd rushed to sign the petition, because it had something to do with punishing a feminist.

This resulted in some pretty amazing petition responses. With no further ado, I give you the ten best reasons to ban me from the Bay Area Science Festival after I retweeted a tweet that linked to a blog post revealing a horrible thing someone else did:

10.

Hard Core: I don't really know what's going on here, or why a doctor would start a rumor about STDs, but this petition was on #gamergate, so I know what I gotta do.

I’ll be honest, this one might be a joke. However, I left a joke comment and it was immediately deleted, so this is apparently good enough for the petitioner to leave in, and therefore worth noting.

9.

Devin Fabricius: I really don't care what this lady said or did. I do not want to know either. I am here to take a stand against these tactics alone. The ends never justify these means.

Devin isn’t really sure what’s going on, but he knows he doesn’t like it! And that’s why he will not be attending my comedy science quiz show with “Survivor” contestant Yau-Man Chan this Saturday.

8.

Sam Keane: Rebecca Watson has promoted pseudoscientific theories such as

This marks the very first time I have ever mentioned the concept of Health at Every Size on this blog, or anywhere else actually. For the record: I think HAES activists get a lot of stuff right and a lot of stuff wrong. Now that I have weighed in (ha ha!) on this issue, I agree that I should definitely not be able to do my comedy science quiz show this Saturday at the Castro Theatre.

7.

Jason Moore: Watson said red blood cells contain DNA *facepalm*

This never happened, but if it had I think we can all agree that it is the best reason to bar someone from performing a comedy science quiz show starring returning champion Phil Plait, “The Bad Astronomer.”

6.

Robyn Ryan: No tolerance for cowards and slanderers.

I’m not sure if Robyn is referring to me, someone who uses her real name and retweets a fact about someone, or Eliza Sutton, someone who uses a pseudonym and starts rumors that her enemies have STDs. Whichever she meant, she is absolutely furious that Bay Area Science Festival would sell tickets for only $10 to Quiz-o-Tron, which will feature comedians Bonnie Burton, Matt Gubser, and Caitlin Gill.

5.

Morten Elving: Rebecca shows huge amounts of hypocrisy, using tactics (which she claims gave her PTSD), to target women with opinions not equal to her own.

To the best of my knowledge, I have never had PTSD. But, maybe Morten Elving is also a doctor like Eliza Sutton, and is actually very good at diagnosing people he hates with disorders. In that case, getting PTSD from someone retweeting a tweet that has my name in it is definitely a good reason to boycott my comedy science quiz show, featuring new contestant Annalee Newitz, editor of io9!

4.

Jesse Paine: Watson's decision to libel a doctor to her employers and to her large internet following is absolutely despicable. This is not a person who values skeptical enquiries and evidence.

Just as a heads up, “libel” does not generally refer to repeating verbatim what someone else has revealed about themselves, nor does it include retweeting such. But if I did libel a doctor, that would absolutely be a great reason to stop this comedy science quiz show from selling tickets at the low, low price of $10.

3.

Bruno Vinogradoff

I assume Bruno is referring to SJW’s, a new social-justice themed chain restaurant currently opening in Target shopping centers across the country. Though I do not own this chain, I am excited about their menu items, like delicious cheese-stuffed FriendZonis. This is absolutely a great reason to have me barred from hosting Quiz-o-Tron, the world’s best comedy science quiz show on October 25 in San Francisco.

2.

Brian Swann: boxing is unacceptable. Period. Full stop.

Though I have never actually boxed, I was considering taking lessons. I probably wouldn’t have time to do it before hosting Quiz-o-Tron at Bay Area Science Festival, but clearly the threat of violence is still there.

1.

Obo Agboghidi: It's shameful that anyone would do this, to suppress opposing views. This isn't how a civilized socoiety works. If Rebecca wants to attack Dr. Sutton work, then attack her work with better proof. Doxxing should not be tolerated.

Obo is absolutely correct. In retrospect, I should have taken the time to fully examine Dr. Sutton’s important work on e-diagnosing people she hates with gonorrhea. What were her methods? Did she get a blood sample from PZ or any of the Skepchick bloggers? Did she access our medical records? These are the questions I should have asked, instead of retweeting that tweet linking to that blog post that pointed out that she said those things. In order to make up for this oversight on my part, I hereby offer to engage Dr. Sutton in a debate over whether PZ Myers has gonorrhea. She may choose the time, the date, the format, and the moderator.

I’m available any time except for October 25, when I’ll be hosting Quiz-o-Tron at the Castro Theatre in San Francisco as part of Bay Area Science Festival.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Pinterest

40 Comments

  1. One day I will actually see a Quiz-O-Tron live, when I have the money to afford plane tickets and hotel and the like. Until then… will it be filmed? I’ll pay to see the video (as long as PayPal isn’t the payment method, because they don’t like me or my money)…

    Also… have fun! Clearly this petition is a failure.

  2. You shouldn’t lie about such things. I’m planning on heading to Target tonight, and now I have my hopes up about SJW’s. A social justice themed restaurant, what’s not to like? And with your endorsement, it’s bound to have vegetarian options, too.

  3. Wasn’t there _something_ about red blood cells and DNA though?

    *traces claim*

    Oh, right you illustrated something about DNA-testing with an image containing red blood cells once. That totally means you shouldn’t be allowed to do this show that’s way too far away from me. In fact I think the US should fly its “perfect scientific accuracy above all”-flag high and deport you to Norway.

    I apologise for thinking you might have forgotten an actual, but trivial. mistake.

    • I could worry about checking that the red blood cells pictured were mammalian (or a very few salamander or fish species) as other vertebrate red blood cells do indeed contain DNA, and that there were no white blood cells (also containing DNA) in the sample from which the picture was taken, but as this comes from GamerGate, I feel absolutely sure the poster fact-checked this first.

      So I’ll skip the fact checking, and go sign that petition. I’ve better things to do with my time, such as to wonder whether “Quiz-o-Tron, the world’s best comedy science quiz show on October 25 in San Francisco” means “Of all the comedy science quiz shows in the world on October 25, Quiz-o-Tron in San Francisco is the best”, or “The October 25 San Francisco edition of Quiz-o-Tron is a quiz show about the world’s best comedy science”, or “Quiz-o-Tron will be asking comedy science questions on the topic of ‘October 25 in San Francisco’, and will do so better than any other ‘October 25 in San Francisco’ quiz show.”

  4. Offtopic, but does anybody know of anything cool happening in San Francisco this Saturday, October 25th at around 9:30pm? Ideally something around $10 and, like, sort of in the panel-quiz-show genre?

  5. I also love the hypocrisy of #1. “Suppressing opposing views is the worst! That’s not how society should work! Let me sign this petition to suppress the views of someone I oppose by cancelling their work!”

  6. Rebecca, I would *totally* be there, but I can’t seem to find out where or when this astounding, once-in-a-lifetime event will occur, nor can I find out who will be there or how much it will cost. (I’ll bet it’s a jaw-droppingly low price, though!)

    Can you help?

  7. Shit guys. I’ve had the wrong definition of libel all this time.

    When you point out something someone actually said, and link to it, it’s libel.

    When you confuse one woman’s actions/statements with another, and then accuse them of it without actually fact checking, it’s standing up to bullying.

    I finally get it now.

  8. I’m surprised this one didn’t make the cut:

    Zeeff Gander SAN FRANCISCO, CA 12 days ago Liked 0
    This is real harassment, not the shenanigans they talk about on twitter

    Because retweeting stuff is SO much worse than what happens on twitter.

  9. I heard about this, and I was afraid some people might cave and actually ban you from Quiz-o-tron. I already bought my tickets, and you are one of the main reasons I want to go. I would be so disappointed if you couldn’t go. You are awesome. Hope to see you at the Bay Area Science Festival!

    I don’t have anything to say about those 10 reasons because for some reason they don’t show up on my computer at work (on Mozilla or Internet Explorer). Ah well, I guess I don’t need to feel shame for humanity anyway.

  10. What? No joke about how they serve beer in Tumblrs at SJW’s? Also, make sure you go to the one at the corner. If it’s not at an intersection, they only serve bovine by-products.

    Anyway, even if she were his doctor, she shouldn’t even be revealing that shit.

  11. I’m an unlicensed hack, er, psychologist and I have just diagnosed Dr. Sutton with a special MD version of Tourette’s Syndrome. Please be gentle with her, like an angry tiger, she can lash out at others without warning. Her specious medical diagnoses are a primary symptom.

  12. I actually live in the Bay Area; however, as much as I adore Rebecca, Phil, and many of the others* at the event, it is also my nephew’s birthday. Priorities. Hope it’s a great show!

    *I’m sure once I am familiar with them that I will adore them, too, but I must have evidence. :)

Leave a Comment

This div height required for enabling the sticky sidebar