Australia’s Social Media Ban is a Win for Gambling Companies
This post contains a video, which you can also view here. To support more videos like this, head to patreon.com/rebecca!
Transcript:
Okay, so a huge content warning: this video is going to start out with depressing news, and it’s not going to get any happier by the end. Well, until the obligatory clip of my dog under the credits. But before that point, I’m going to be talking about self harm and violence and government ineptitude. If any of those is going to bring you too much horror during a time that should be joyful, go ahead and just skip to the end to watch Indy prancing around the Oakland hills.
Back in 2024, I went over the evidence for and against Jonathan Haidt’s assertion that social media is rewiring kids’ brains and causing a mental health crisis. The tl;dw is that the actual scientists who are studying this have yet to find any evidence that that’s true: social media obviously has its problems, and it sucks in a number of ways for kids AND adults, but there’s nothing about it that is actually causing mental health issues in children as a population. There’s just as much cause to say “social media is bad for kids” as it is to say television, video games, or rock music is “bad for kids.”
I bring this back up now because despite the lack of evidence of harm, governments around the planet are considering laws, and in some cases actually passing laws, ostensibly to try to stop kids from accessing social media. I’ll get into that in more detail in a minute, but first I want to talk about two of the tragic cases that are giving these laws steam–cases that are in the news right now because of a new lawsuit.
Two families, one here in the US and the other in Scotland, have filed a lawsuit against Meta for causing the deaths of their teenaged sons, who both died of suicide after being extorted by scammers through Instagram direct messages who threatened to release sexual images of the boys.
These “sextortion” cases have been on the rise in recent years, with scammers usually pretending to be peers of boys and convincing them to send intimate pictures to them. They then claim to have the ability to send those images to the kids’ contacts unless they are paid hundreds or thousands of dollars.
Murray Dowey of Scotland was 16 at the end of 2023, and his family thought he was absolutely fine before he left a family gathering, went to his room, and killed himself. A search of his phone revealed that he had been communicating with scammers just before he did it.
Levi Maciejewski was only 13 in 2024 when the exact same thing happened to him.
The reaction to the lawsuit on social media, as far as I’ve seen, has been to completely support the families and to shit on Meta for being an evil corporation that is clearly and obviously negligent when it comes to protecting minors who use its products. And why shouldn’t that be the reaction? Meta is FAMOUS for putting profits over human lives, to the point of allowing nefarious actors to use Facebook to literally perpetuate a genocide in Myanmar, and to get Trump elected, and to spread hate speech in Ethiopia. “Evil” tends to be a religious concept with a lot of baggage that erases all subtlety but yeah, if anything is evil, Meta is fucking evil.
But I do think it’s worthwhile to back up and appreciate some of the subtlety, specifically because these cases are being used to support social media bans. These tragic cases do not erase the actual research that shows that social media is, as per the name, a medium. That medium can be used for ill, like in these cases, but the laws being passed are not necessarily the solution to that.
As I said in that previous video about Haidt’s pseudoscientific claim that social media is “rewiring” kids’ brains, part of the problem with banning kids from social media is that it’s an overly simplistic act that allows parents and governments to feel like they’ve done enough, and then ignoring all of the things that are actually causing kids to have mental health problems.
Take Levi Maciejewski, for instance. He was only 13, and had only been on Instagram two days before he took his life. How did he do that? He used a gun. A gun that his family had, in his home, with bullets. Why did this child have access to a loaded gun? Would he have killed himself if it had been just a little easier? Sadly, we do not know.
In the case of Murray Dowey, his family admits that they knew he had been on Instagram since he was ten years old, despite the fact that Instagram already restricted its use to kids over the age of 13. Obviously, it’s understandable that his family didn’t realize an app for sharing pictures could be so dangerous for a child, but this shows how it’s not quite as easy as simply increasing the age at which kids are allowed to access social media.
And I’ve talked before about how the attempts to improve the ability of these apps to restrict access to kids are doomed to fail at their stated goal, and in fact only exist to increase profits for the corporations selling age verification while making everyone less safe and less private. There’s a reason these age verification services are owned by gaming and pornography companies, who then lobby governments to force websites to use them.
That’s why I wasn’t surprised to see who was behind the law that recently took effect in Australia, where YouTube, TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, and Snapchat are now banned for any kids under the age of 16. Australians were told the campaign to enact the law was a “grassroots” organization called 36 Months.
In reality, 36 Months was created during a single meeting in the boardroom of FINCH, an advertising company with several high-profile clients that dealt in gambling, like Ladbroke, Sportsbet, CrownBet, and TAB Australia. In fact, as reported by the independent news outlet Crikey (incredible name), during that very meeting, other employees at FINCH were working on a spot that would go on to become the third most-complained-about ad in New Zealand that year.
Staff from FINCH, which was the primary funder of 36 Months, worked double duty on the nonprofit, which lobbied the Australian government to ban that handful of social media sites, none of which included any gambling or gaming apps despite the fact that kids absolutely use those apps to connect with friends, and despite the fact that prior to the campaign, the Australian government had been seriously considering a total ban on online gambling advertising. In November of this year, the Financial Review reported that the government was dropping that ban and “using the under-16 social media restrictions as cover to water down the policy.”
If you’re a fan of Coffeezilla, and you should be, you know that the “gamblification of everything” has been happening for some time now, with corporations using every loophole they can to introduce people, especially and including children, to gambling away their money. Experts have been warning for YEARS about gaming companies using “lootboxes” and other psychological tricks to get kids addicted to gambling, and now Roblox is just full on doing it.
This study from Australian researchers was published earlier this year–they gave a few dozen kids $20 to spend literally however they wanted. Four of them bought non-digital items like bike parts and candy. Twelve of them spent it all on Roblox, and they reported ““scary” and complex transactions, describe(d) random reward systems as “child gambling”, and talk(ed) of “scams” and “cash grabs”, with the platform’s inflexible refund policy providing little recourse.”
And here’s what the sociopath in charge of Roblox had to say recently on a podcast.
How many kids will end up mentally fucked up because they lost all their money gambling? How many will consider suicide rather than tell their parents, especially if they used their parents’ money?
And what’s the solution? Ban kids from gambling? Well yes, obviously, but just like with social media, that will not fix the core problem. Like, that Roblox guy should be in prison. Seriously. But ultimately, we have to fix the capitalistic forces that push ad agencies to lobby governments to take symbolic actions while dropping real legislation that would improve lives. We have to stop letting any corporations lobby our governments in their favor. We have to prioritize the actual science that helps us understand the problem and potential solutions. We have to destroy the gun culture that allows a child to take his own life within a minute of making the decision. We have to empower parents to understand the dangers their kids face and give them the tools to educate and protect their kids from predatory people and companies. It sucks that we can’t just snap our fingers, kill social media, and everything is fixed. It’s complicated, and it requires a multi-pronged plan of action.
I’ll end with an anecdote. I actually grew up gambling. I played poker for money before I could even hold the cards…my parents made slits in a block of foam so I could set the cards up in front of me. When I was about 10 I hit the jackpot on a children’s slot machine at Six Flags Great Adventure and I used the tokens to buy a roulette set, which became the anchor of my bedroom casino where my friends would play games and I, as the house, would take their money. One day I was babysitting a 7-year old boy who had $20, which he bet and lost in a blackjack game just as his mom pulled up to the house to pick him up. Our moms walked in and he was sitting in front of a bunch of cards, crying. Like, BAWLING. I argued that he knew the rules of the game and he lost. My mom argued that he was 7, I was an asshole, and I had to give him his $20 back. I did. I was salty about it for a bit, but pretty quickly thought it over and realized my mom was right. I took advantage of a little kid who may have known the rules of blackjack, but he didn’t understand the odds, or the consequences of losing. He just thought of the joy of winning. And I felt like an asshole, and from then on I went back to playing poker with my parents’ friends, who for the record never gave me my money back when I lost. But I knew the odds.
Anyway, I learned that lesson when I was ten. I’m pretty sure the guys running these rackets are never going to learn it from empathy, so the rest of us are going to have to work together to make sure they learn it the hard way.