Are Raccoons Being Domesticated?
This post contains a video, which you can also view here. To support more videos like this, head to patreon.com/rebecca!
Transcript:
I’ve talked about this before, but I swear it’s relevant and some of you are new here, so: 8 years ago, I found Indy as a homeless 3-month old puppy. He looked like this. I got him because I was severely depressed and my psychiatrist thought a dog would help. A dog, not a puppy.
Because, dear viewer, I spent much of our first few months together actively trying to keep him alive. Not only was he trying to jump out windows and eating whatever he happened to find on the ground, but there were days when I honestly wanted to throw him out the window myself. If you’ve never had to take care of a puppy alone while severely depressed, let me tell you, it’s not fun. He refused to poop outside for weeks. He chewed anything that was within chewing distance. He cried whenever I left him alone in another room. And while I think of myself as someone who would never, ever hurt an innocent animal because they were annoying the shit out of me, I have to admit there were times when I wondered if one reason I made it through those first few months were because Indy looked like this. He would look up from gnawing on an expensive shoe with those giant brown eyes and the velvety soft ears and his fluffy little tail and all my annoyance would melt away. Well, most of my annoyance. Enough that instead of yelling or forced defenestration, I would replace the shoe with a Kong and give him a little smooch on his snoot.
A lot of research has gone into figuring out the reason why Indy is so cute. Well, not just Indy but all domestic dogs, and cats, and recently, raccoons. Yes, raccoons. Today I want to talk about why raccoons are so cute, and in classic Rebecca fashion I started this video as a fun diversion from talking about things that make my brain hurt and obviously I fell into a cute fluffy little rabbit’s hole in the process.
The topic of raccoon cuteness is hot right now in part because TikTok and other social media sites are full of chatter about a recent study that suggests that raccoons are becoming domesticated. Raccoons have long been one of the internet’s favorite meme animals, so obviously this research has a lot of people hopeful that they will soon have a funny little trash panda of their own.
Tracking domestication signals across populations of North American raccoons (Procyon lotor) via citizen science-driven image repositories was published in October in Frontiers in Zoology, and it encompasses a few of my favorite things: cute animals, yes, but also it’s open access AND involves citizen science efforts that I myself have participated in! Specifically, they used raccoon photos taken by regular people and uploaded to iNaturalist, which logs the species, date, and time of each observation.
Fun fact about iNaturalist: I’ve used it to help various projects like tide pool “bioblitzes” and researchers studying how high and low king tides get around the Bay Area. But a few months ago I was reading about a woman who murdered her family by feeding them poisonous mushrooms, which she harvested herself after looking up posts on iNaturalist. That is obviously horrible and no one should do that, but also…I’ve been learning about mushroom foraging and had never thought of using iNaturalist to help find them. I immediately opened up the app, sorted by recent observations of fungi, and then went out on a hike to find the mushrooms and observe their characteristics. It was really fun. Like Pokemon Go but if you eat the Pokemon you might trip balls or die.
Anyway.
These researchers, led by Dr. Raffaela Lesch, a biologist at the University of Arkansas at Little Rock, gathered 20,000 photos of raccoons and compared measurements of their snouts. They found that raccoons in urban areas had snouts that were 3.5 percent shorter than raccoons in rural areas.
Why does that matter? Because of something called “domestication syndrome,” which is the hypothesis that suggests that all domesticated animals develop certain physical characteristics regardless of how or why they were domesticated. For instance, we might want to domesticate a certain wild animal to, say, produce a delicious milk for our morning coffee. Domestication syndrome suggests that even though we’d be breeding to select for their milk, that wild animal will also end up smaller, less aggressive towards humans, and with floppier ears and a fluffier tail and, yes, a shorter muzzle.
So, Lesch argues in this paper that the shorter snouts on urban raccoons may be evidence that they are becoming more domesticated in the same way that dogs likely became domesticated: living in close proximity to humans, and finding ways to get access to our scraps either by outsmarting our trashcans or just looking so darn cute we can’t help but give them the occasional snacky snack.
Makes sense, right? Well, some people aren’t so sure. Nessie O’Neil is a popular TikTok creator who claims to be a raccoon biologist–this isn’t me being shady, just accurate. I am not a raccoon biologist, or any kind of biologist, so it doesn’t invalidate whatever she has to say. I just wasn’t able to find any information about her CV or research but her website only says that she works for an exotic pet sanctuary, which is awesome but I just want to be clear that I have no idea what her actual expertise is. That said, I did find her video rebutting this new study to be interesting. I won’t play the entire thing because it’s long by TikTok standards, but she makes a few points I’d like to highlight. The bulk of the video concerns her claim that these authors have simply “rediscovered” raccoon subspecies, and that explains all of their results.
I had to replay this a few times because for the life of me I couldn’t find the “subspecies” column in the data I had. Eventually I realized I couldn’t find it because she’s saying that she added that column in by labeling each observation herself using “maps and studies on raccoon biology.”
Here’s the thing: “subspecies” are a mess. They can interbreed with one another (which is why they’re the same species) and are distinguished by taxonomists based upon where they live and what they look like. But that is exactly what this study is looking at! How a species differs depending upon where they live and what they look like! So she has essentially removed the relevant data in order to claim that the conclusion is incorrect. It isn’t.
Imagine I have a population of rats living in my garage and a separate population of rats living in my bedroom and sometimes napping with me in bed. Over many generations, these two populations are different enough that I dub one to be the subspecies of “garage rats” with the distinct traits of living in the garage and possessing longer snouts and a higher tendency to bite, and the other to be the subspecies of “bed rats” with the distinct traits of living in the bedroom and possessing shorter snouts and a lower tendency to bite. If I publish a study showing that proximity to humans appears to result in rats with shorter snouts and a more charming personality, you can’t debunk that by saying “well you’re comparing garage rats to bed rats so it’s not valid.”
There IS an argument to be made in a messier real-world scenario like raccoons, in that populations overlap more and subspecies may change after the human population in a particular area increases, but you can’t explore that by looking at a dataset with no photos and just guessing at what subspecies that raccoon may be and going with whatever the average snout length is for that subspecies.
O’Neil’s opening point is the one I found more interesting: she says that this study is flawed in part because it is entirely based upon a prior flawed study. She’s referring to this paper from 1979, titled “Destabilizing selection as a factor in domestication” by Dmitry Belyayev, a Russian biologist who was committed to understanding how we ended up with dogs, and so conducted an elaborate experiment breeding foxes only for their behavior and observing what morphological changes occurred alongside. This is where the “domestication syndrome” hypothesis comes from: as they only bred the tamest foxes, over the generations not only did the foxes become tamer, but their snouts shorter, their ears floppier, their fur lighter, and their tails bushier. This mirrors many of the changes we see in other domesticated animals like dogs and mice, suggesting there might be some underlying connection.
O’Neil dismisses Belyayev by pointing out that he failed to domesticate another species, river otters, insinuating that the otters got pointier snouts or less fluffy tails or something. In fact, he was unable to complete the experiment on otters because he couldn’t get them to reproduce. Breeding is kind of an essential aspect of observing the results of selective breeding.
She then dismisses the fox study because Belyayev sourced the foxes from fur farms. That IS actually a fair criticism. Belyayev was always up front about where he sourced his foxes, but in the decades since a popular misconception formed that he had actually used wild foxes that he then “domesticated.” That, of course, does nothing to invalidate his study. That said, in 2020, a team of biologists published an opinion piece in Trends in Ecology and Evolution pointing out that many of the physical changes observed in the foxes in the experiment had already begun to be selected for on the farms, something that Belyayev may not have even realized.
Does it invalidate the silver fox experiment? Absolutely not. It doesn’t even invalidate the domestication syndrome hypothesis. It’s still just a hypothesis, with some data supporting it and some data opposing it. Those biologists argue that the fox experiment is important but its conclusions overstated, and so we should collect more data and explore other hypotheses to explain what we see in domesticated animals.
And that, my friends, is exactly what this new study does. It does not in any way “prove” that raccoons are becoming domesticated, regardless of what people on TikTok or even mainstream news headlines might suggest. That would take two leaps: one, that shorter snouts are a guaranteed sign of domestication, and two, that raccoons’ snouts are getting shorter because of domestication and not another reason, like a changing climate. In this study, the researchers found that “Urban raccoons in cold climates have shorter snouts than their rural counterparts, but they may have longer snouts than rural raccoons from very hot climates.” There are a lot of reasons why species might develop different physical traits, and this study is in no way comprehensive enough to establish a causal connection.
But again, that’s okay! That doesn’t mean, as O’Neil suggests in other videos, it should be retracted. Not every study needs to establish proof of a groundbreaking new theory. Their conclusion is quite conservative: “raccoons in close contact with densely populated human environments experience a reduction in snout length,” which lends support to the current most popular (but still hotly debated) mechanistic explanation for Domestication Syndrome, making raccoons a good population to study if we hope to observe a species domesticating in real time. They then caution that their results also show how environmental pressures, like the climate, can complicate these observations. Reasonable.
I’m happy that researchers are using tools like iNaturalist to collect data and add more research to support or rebut popular hypotheses about the flora and fauna we interact with. After all, they COULD be using it to find poisonous mushrooms to murder people.
