Bad Beetle Karma

bug bag

I realized after my interview last weekend that I had never actually covered Japanese Beetle Bags on the blog!  That omission must be remedied!

I’m sure you’ve seen them–they are for sale all over.   The sad truth is that they don’t work.

Sure, they fill up the bag-o’-death in a really satisfying way, but they also attract many, many more beetles into the area that don’t get caught.  As long ago as 1985, there was pretty clear evidence that putting the bags out actually made the damage from the beetles worse.

Beetle bags contain a combination of lures–the bright yellow color mimics flowers, there’s a feeding attractant, and also a female sex pheromone.  It is the buggy equivalent of a giant flashing neon sign advertizing a message equivalent to “FREE SEX ORGY AND ALL YOU CAN EAT BBQ WINGS + BEER”.

graph

A lot of beetles come to the trap–but less than 25% of the beetles attracted actually go into it.

Really.

Here, look at the data.

That’s from a 2009 study that looked at the specific behavior of beetles attracted to the trap.  They concluded that it’s not a problem with trap design; it’s a problem with beetle brains.  Scarabs are notoriously poor fliers; a few will probably bean you at top speed if you stand around outside long enough in the summer.

Their braking strategy is about the same as the one I use on rollerblades–find a large object, smash into it, and hang on.

So, thousands of Japanese beetles fly into the area where the trap is and most of them miss it.  They hang around the trap–because they know that orgy must be around here somewhere–and eventually hook up and start eating. Outside the trap.

Some of them do eventually find their way into the bag later on, but the total catch is still pretty dismal. And you just paid money to bring all these pest insects into your yard. Oops.

One recommendation that’s commonly made, since the traps do work, just not the way we want, is to buy them and give them to the neighbor you hate the most.  Then their garden will be gobbled up, and your beetles will all fly over there.

Sounds great, right? Except. Here is where the Karma comes in.

One of the reasons these beetles are so evil is they have a 1-2 punch.  No only do they eat your fruit and veg, they lay their eggs in your yard. And eat your grass from the roots.

So, if you send all your beetles over to your neighbor’s yard with the traps…they will lay thousands of eggs over there. And even more beetles will come right back to you as punishment for your Karmic Transgression when the grubs emerge from his/her yard.   Payback is a bitch.

So how can you control them? Honestly, I have had the best success with a Mason jar full of soapy water. Find a small kid and tell them you’ll give them a penny for each beetle in the jar. Problem solved.

You might also enjoy this video about Japanese Beetle Control created by the University of Maine.  Ayup!

References:

Switzer, P., Enstrom, P., & Schoenick, C. (2009). Behavioral Explanations Underlying the Lack of Trap Effectiveness for Small-Scale Management of Japanese Beetles (Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae) Journal of Economic Entomology, 102 (3), 934-940 DOI: 10.1603/029.102.0311
Gordon, F. C., & D. A. Potter (1985). Efficiency of Japanese beetle (Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae) traps in reducing defoliation of plants in the urban landscape and effect on larval density in turf. J. Econ. Entomology, 78, 774-778

Avatar of bug_girl
Bug_girl has a PhD in Entomology, and is a pointy-headed former academic living in Ohio. She is obsessed with insects, but otherwise perfectly normal. Really! If you want a daily stream of cool info about bugs, follow her Facebook page or find her on Twitter.

14 Comments

  1. Avatar of Cassandra

    I’ve always seen those bags around but never actually knew what they were until now. My parents always had a pretty pro-bug policy for our yard/ garden and never tried to mess with anything too much. The only thing we ever really did was plant Marigolds.

  2. Avatar of Rei Malebario

    I read “japanese beetle bags” and assumed these would be bags shaped like a beetle or something. You can imagine my bitter disappointment.

  3. Avatar of QuestionAuthority

    The only time we had japanese beetles was when we had some tea roses. Once they munched them to death, they left. (shrug) Of course, my annual Preying Mantis release might have something to do with that, too. :-)

  4. Avatar of ekimbrough

    Reminds me of bug zappers, a product too annoying to be allowed to exist. They can preferentially kill harmless and beneficial insects while mosquitoes ignore the light that’s supposed to attract them. Also, the zapping is so thorough that bug parts can spray out over a seven foot radius in a mist that can be a good bacterial medium. (Some more recent designs suppress this, though I hate saying anything good about them.)

    Finally, as with the beetle bags, I’ve heard claims that they attract more than they kill, so you’re annoyed by even more insects while you’re annoyed by the zapping.

  5. Avatar of waltdakind

    I have (fond?) childhood memories of being conscripted by my parents to collect Japanese beetles in jars. Glad to know that this was a more effective method than using the bags would have been.

  6. Avatar of killyosaur

    well that kind of sucks to learn. My parents have been using the bags, but apparently that has just been making things worse instead of better. Will have to not that to them next time I see them :-/

  7. Avatar of nokidsdammit

    Though the full bags hanging about a foot off the ground make excellent snacks for raccoons. Who chew a handy hole in the bag to dispense the yummy, crunchy snack more easily.

  8. Avatar of Lynn Wilhelm

    As a horticulturalist, I’ve always advised people to forget about these, or try the neighbor approach.

    I rarely have trouble with them any more and usually recommend people pick them off–cool mornings are best (we haven’t had many of those this summer!). I’ve also had a Japanese Maple denuded by the things and the leaves came out again. Here in NC our beetles come out in June so there’s lots of summer left for plants to recover. In northern climes there might not be enough time.

  9. Avatar of BeardofPants

    Ok, I lol’d at the bit about revenge on neighbors. Really? People are that petty? Like all, “I declare WAR with my beetle bag!! RRAARRRGGHH!” ?

  10. Avatar of BlackCat

    Looking on the wikipedia article, they mention using a disease (bacteria) against the larvae to kill them. Does this work?

    I looked it up because I was curious if we had them. Being out west, no, we don’t. Whew.

  11. Avatar of freemage

    The penny-a-bug notion amused me, only because that was how my grandfather (a lifelong, hard-core smoker) would ensure that no cigarette butts were left behind after a summer vacation at Higgins Lake in northern Michigan. After a two-month stay, there was good money to be made, even at a penny per butt (he liked to walk the grounds around the cabin when he was smoking).

  12. Avatar of lazyskeptic

    Wait a minute. Aren’t you bug girl? I thought you had a superpower to control the tiny primitive things?I can see that my flamboyant fantasy was very wrong.

Add Comment Register



Leave a Reply